Scoring Framework

  • RReachUser percentage affected1-5
  • IImpactPain severity + moat potential0.5-3.0
  • CConfidenceEvidence strength + conviction it will work50-100%
  • EEffortRelative engineering complexity0.5-4
RICE = (R × I × C) / E
Final Score = Base RICE × Theme Multiplier

The scores are estimates from the research, not usage data. A WHOOP team would re-score with real reach and engineering estimates.

Strategic Multipliers

Standard RICE optimises for velocity, naturally deprioritising high-effort problems. To align with the Blue Ocean positioning (Adaptation + Biometrics), theme multipliers were applied:

  1. 1.8xSystem Rigidityadaptive plans, the core differentiator
  2. 1.6xPersonalisationbiometric baselines, the data advantage
  3. 1.2xTransparencytrust builders, relatively easy
  4. 1.1xImpractical Adviceshows travel understanding
  5. 1.0xSetup Complexitytable stakes

Tiering: Strategic Bets and Quick Wins

The 12 highest-scoring problems are the scope, in two tiers. This balances differentiation with polish. Once the product solution was complete, it was checked against this list: v1 also covers 11 of the other problems.

  • Strategic Betsexploit gaps competitors can't fill and create the moat.Tier 0
  • Quick Winsbuild trust with lower effort.Tier 1
  • Also covered in v1

Complete Problem List (34 Problems)

Problem StatementThemeRICEBaseMultFinal
Quick Win (Tier 1): Time zone display unclear throughout interfaceTransparency41.5100%0.512.01.2x14.4
Quick Win (Tier 1): Melatonin dosage and timing guidance unclearTransparency32.0100%0.512.01.2x14.4
Strategic Bet (Tier 0): No feedback mechanism for actual sleep behaviourRigidity53.0100%27.51.8x13.5
Strategic Bet (Tier 0): No adaptation when user deviates from planRigidity53.0100%27.51.8x13.5
Strategic Bet (Tier 0): Plans ignore individual chronotype differencesPersonalisation53.0100%27.51.6x12.0
Quick Win (Tier 1): No guidance on meal timing for circadian alignmentImpractical32.080%0.59.61.1x10.56
Quick Win (Tier 1): Recommendations lack contextual explanationsTransparency42.0100%18.01.2x9.6
Strategic Bet (Tier 0): Rigid structure assumes perfect executionRigidity42.5100%25.01.8x9.0
Quick Win (Tier 1): Light recommendations ignore environmental constraintsImpractical42.0100%18.01.1x8.8
Quick Win (Tier 1): Sleep recommendations ignore boarding proceduresImpractical42.0100%18.01.1x8.8
Quick Win (Tier 1): Pre-departure wake times conflict with workImpractical42.0100%18.01.1x8.8
Quick Win (Tier 1): Activity instructions lack specificityTransparency31.580%0.57.21.2x8.64
Cannot account for seat class sleep differencesPersonalisation32.080%14.81.6x7.68
Plans break when flights delayed or cancelledRigidity42.0100%24.01.8x7.2
Also covered in v1: No alternative strategies when primary plan failsRigidity42.580%24.01.8x7.2
Also covered in v1: Health data usage invisible despite claimsTransparency32.580%16.01.2x7.2
Also covered in v1: Timeline navigation prevents forward planningSetup41.5100%16.01.0x6.0
Also covered in v1: Cannot mark tasks as missed or skippedRigidity42.080%23.21.8x5.76
Also covered in v1: Insight metrics shown without explanationTransparency31.080%0.54.81.2x5.76
Sleep timing conflicts with flight meal serviceImpractical42.0100%24.01.1x4.4
Also covered in v1: Cannot re-enter rerouted flights without restartingRigidity32.080%22.41.8x4.32
Ignores individual caffeine sensitivityPersonalisation32.080%22.41.6x3.84
Sleep preferences captured as whole-hours onlyPersonalisation30.580%0.52.41.6x3.84
Also covered in v1: Circadian progress not visible during adjustmentTransparency32.580%23.01.2x3.6
Also covered in v1: No consideration for medications and conditionsPersonalisation22.580%22.01.6x3.2
Also covered in v1: No calendar or email integration for flightsSetup41.5100%23.01.0x3.0
Multi-city trips require separate plansRigidity22.080%21.61.8x2.88
Advice incompatible with family responsibilitiesImpractical31.5100%22.251.1x2.48
No quick setup for frequently travelled routesSetup21.580%12.41.0x2.4
Interface doesn't learn from previous tripsPersonalisation32.580%41.51.6x2.4
Post-trip feedback doesn't improve future plansRigidity32.080%41.21.8x2.16
Also covered in v1: Flight entry requires exact flight numbersSetup41.0100%22.01.0x2.0
No adaptation for jet lag accumulationPersonalisation23.080%41.21.6x1.92
Also covered in v1: No indication of confidence level in adviceTransparency21.050%11.01.2x1.2
Back to Prioritisation